SEC Plan to Gut Executive Pay Disclosures Adds to Mounting Concerns Over Market Transparency
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
SEC proposal would end say-on-pay votes at most public companies and strip away the data investors use to hold boards accountable for CEO pay.
MEDIA CONTACT: Ryon Harms, [email protected], (310) 730-9407
EL CERRITO, CALIFORNIA—November 20, 2026 – As You Sow strongly objects to the Securities and Exchange Commission’s latest proposal to dismantle executive compensation disclosure. This is the latest step in an ongoing process of suppressing the material information that distinguishes the U.S. market. This SEC-driven campaign is anti-competitive, anti-democratic, and anti-capitalistic. Fiduciary duty requires making informed decisions based on the free flow of information.
As You Sow used this information for more than a decade to provide its annual report, The 100 Most Overpaid CEOs. In every edition, companies with the most overpaid CEOs delivered lower returns than the average S&P 500 company. The ten most overpaid CEOs underperformed the index by 2 to 13 percentage points, depending on the year. A rolling portfolio of the 100 most overpaid companies returned 20 percentage points less than the S&P 500 average over seven years. That analysis, and every investor portfolio decision built on it, depends on the disclosures the SEC now wants to take away.
The SEC’s proposal would cut required pay disclosure from five executives to two, the CEO and CFO. It would eliminate the pay-versus-performance table. It would also hollow out the CEO pay ratio by counting only U.S. full-time workers and letting companies identify the median employee just once every five years. A separate SEC proposal would exempt companies with less than $2 billion in public float, roughly 81% of public companies by the SEC’s own estimate, from Say-on-Pay votes, pay ratio disclosure, and, critically, pay-versus-performance disclosure. Newly public companies of any size would also be exempt for their first five years.
“I’ve said it before, killing the canary does not make the mine safer,” said Andrew Behar, CEO of As You Sow. “It just makes it riskier. This is what the SEC is doing to the U.S. markets, increasing risk as it reduces information. The proposed rescission of the Climate Disclosure and the rules governing shareholder proposals are just the most obvious signs of how new SEC rules are choking off critical sources of information. Shareholders call on all companies that want to build trust with their shareholders to continue to disclose Say-on-Pay voluntarily, to continue to provide climate-related disclosures, and to post shareholder proposals, which provide a wealth of information to companies and shareholders, on their proxies.”
Say-on-Pay did not happen by accident. Shareholders fought for it beginning in 2006. Investors filed more than 300 say-on-pay resolutions over five proxy seasons. Average support climbed above 46% by 2009, majorities voted yes at 24 companies that year alone, and dozens of companies, starting with Aflac, adopted the vote voluntarily. Because so many companies already offered it, Congress made Say-on-Pay universal in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act. The goal was comparability; the single most important tool investors have for judging one company against another. Shareholders were given the right to choose whether the vote is held every one, two, or three years.
Dodd-Frank also required companies to disclose the ratio of CEO pay to the pay of their median worker. That data revealed ratios topping 1,000:1 and gave investors a clear measure of whether pay is grounded in reality.
As You Sow urges investors, fiduciaries, and the public to submit comments opposing these proposals before the SEC’s deadline of January 19, 2027
# # #
As You Sow is the nation’s leading shareholder representative, with a 30+ year track record promoting environmental and social corporate responsibility. As You Sow addresses a range of issues that affect shareholder value including toxins in the food system, climate change, ocean plastics, biodiversity, racial justice, and workplace diversity. See As You Sow’s shareholder resolution tracker.